You packed four thousand lunches. You showed up at the school nurse in your slippers. You only forgot one of us at church once. And some nights you still wonder if you got it right.
So we looked into it. We formed a committee. The committee counted ashtrays. The evidence is conclusive: the other moms on our street drank and smoked way more than you.
One neighbour at a time, her favorite child presents the evidence. Mrs. Pruitt and her eleven ashtrays. Mrs. Duvall and the iced tea that needed its own cooler. Mrs. Lyle and the punch with a second punch in it. Next to them, Mom looks like a saint. She was.
Two spreads, as they are printed, full colour to the edge.
Remember when Mrs. Pruitt smoked in the bathroom with the door shut? We knew. The towels knew. The wallpaper knew.
You smoked on the porch, and waved the smoke toward the neighbours like you were being polite.
At every cookout, Mrs. Duvall's iced tea needed its own cooler. Everybody knew it was spiked. You had one wine cooler. You held it like it might go off. Every time somebody walked by you said, "I'm having one." Nobody asked.
Ashtray count, by house. Pruitt: eleven, including the bathroom and the car. Ours: one.
Things Mom Said, suitable for framing. Mom's Cures, of which the leading one was "You'll live." We did. The Moms of Our Street yearbook, Class of 1975. And It Really Was Like That, ten exhibits of true facts about how it was, with sources, because somebody will ask.
Your Favorite Child has published three titles with this house and has never given us a legal name. The founder set that precedent in 1732 and we have not revisited it.
Correspondence reaches the author care of a mother who, we are told, still keeps the list.
Seventy two pages in full colour to tell a woman she did a good job. She knows. She has known since 1979. The ashtray count is the only arithmetic in the book and it was produced by a subcommittee that was caught in the act of producing it.
One star. The mother deserves better than a committee.